Investing in stocks and bonds are two of the most common ways for individuals to grow their money over time. Both offer potential returns, but they function differently and have distinct advantages and disadvantages that investors should understand before deciding where to put their money. This comprehensive guide provides an in-depth comparison of stocks vs bonds to help investors determine which, if either, is the better choice for their financial goals and risk tolerance.
What are Stocks?
Stocks, also known as equities, represent ownership in a company. When you purchase shares of stock, you are buying a small fraction of that company. In return, you may receive dividend payments if the company performs well and chooses to distribute some of its profits. You also have the potential to generate capital gains if you sell the stock for more than you initially paid.
Publicly traded companies issue stock that is bought and sold on stock exchanges like the New York Stock Exchange and the Nasdaq. The price per share rises and falls based on supply and demand as well as factors related to the company’s financials and outlook. Stocks are considered riskier investments because share prices can fluctuate significantly in the short-term. However, over long periods, stocks have tended to provide higher returns compared to other assets.
What are Bonds?
Bonds are debt instruments issued by governments, municipalities, and corporations to raise capital. When you purchase a bond, you are loaning money to the bond issuer. In return, they promise to pay you interest on the loan and repay the principal when the bond reaches maturity.
For example, if you buy a 5-year corporate bond with a face value of $1,000 and a 5% coupon rate, the company will pay you $50 in annual interest. At the end of the 5-year term, you get your $1,000 principal back. Bonds are considered less risky because, if the issuer defaults, bondholders are paid before stockholders.
The interest payments and return of principal at maturity provide a predictable income stream. However, bond prices can still fluctuate based on factors like interest rates and the financial health of the issuer. Capital gains or losses can occur if sold before maturity.
Key Differences Between Stocks and Bonds
Now that you understand the basics of what stocks and bonds are, let’s explore the critical differences between the two asset classes:
Ownership vs. Debt
The most fundamental difference is that stocks represent ownership, while bonds are debt. As a stockholder, you own a piece of the company and have a claim on its assets and earnings. As a bondholder, you are entitled to promised interest payments and the return of principal – nothing more.
Higher Potential Returns vs. Lower Risk
Over the long run, stocks have provided average annual returns of around 10%, significantly higher than the 5-6% average for bonds. However, on a year-to-year basis, stock returns can vary wildly. Bonds provide steady interest income and greater price stability, though yields are lower.
Price Volatility vs. Interest Rate Risk
Stock prices bounce up and down constantly in response to company events, economic factors, investor sentiment and more. Bonds fluctuate in value too, but to a lesser degree. With bonds, the main risk is interest rate changes. Rising rates reduce existing bond prices since new bonds are issued at higher yields.
Growth vs. Income Orientation
Stocks are better suited for investors focused on growing their money over decades. The potential for high long-term returns makes stocks a good way to save for goals far in the future. Bonds work for investors who want regular income. The predictable interest payments provide cash flow.
Tax Treatment Differences
Stock dividends and any capital gains from selling shares are taxed at favorable long-term capital gains rates if held over one year. Interest income from bonds is taxed as ordinary income at rates up to 37% federally. An exception is municipal bonds, which are exempt from federal taxes.
Pros and Cons of Investing in Stocks
|Higher long-term return potential
|Prices fluctuate and can drop sharply
|Capital gains tax rates are favorable
|Dividends can be reduced or suspended
|Ownership benefits like voting rights
|Individual companies can perform poorly
|There are a wide range of companies to invest in
|Requires research to pick winning stocks
|Can sell anytime the market is open
|Commissions to buy and sell shares
Pros and Cons of Investing in Bonds
|Predictable interest income
|Lower long-term returns than stocks
|Low price volatility
|Interest income taxed at higher rates
|Get your principal back at maturity
|Bond prices fall when rates rise
|Low correlation with stocks
|Limited upside potential
|Hold individual bonds or bond funds
|Illiquidity of individual bonds
|Fixed maturities align with goals
|Inflation can reduce purchasing power
Key Factors to Consider When Deciding Between Stocks and Bonds
- Time Horizon – Stocks reward long-term investors who can ride out volatility. Bonds work better for short and mid-term goals.
- Risk Tolerance – Those with low risk tolerance favor bonds. Stocks suit investors who are comfortable with price swings for higher returns.
- Income Needs – Bonds provide regular interest income. Stocks offer potential for higher income long-term through dividends.
- Tax Implications – Weigh capital gains rates for stocks against higher ordinary income rates for bonds.
- Other Investments – Balance a stock-heavy portfolio with some bonds. Or use bonds if you own real estate.
- Personal Factors – Consider your age, career stability, knowledge, and emotional temperament.
Example Scenarios for Choosing Stocks or Bonds
Below are a few examples highlighting when stocks or bonds may be more suitable:
- A 25-year-old just starting their career has a long career horizon until retirement. Investing mainly in stocks provides higher growth potential early on.
- A 50-year-old with a moderate risk tolerance could put some money in bonds to generate income and balance their stock holdings.
- An entrepreneur selling their business wants to put the proceeds into a low-risk investment. Bonds preserve capital and provide income.
- A young family saving for college in 10 years should emphasize bonds over volatile stocks for this short-term goal.
- A retiree seeking income could build a laddered bond portfolio with regular interest payments to supplement Social Security.
- A charitable foundation with multi-million dollar assets can afford some stock market risk to grow its endowment over decades.
Stocks and Bonds: Better Together
Rather than choosing between stocks and bonds, the best approach for most long-term investors is to hold a mix of both.
Owning stocks provides greater growth potential that bonds cannot match. Bonds supply fixed income and stability during periods when stocks underperform. Blending stocks and bonds creates a balanced portfolio aligned with your risk preferences.
Rebalancing periodically maintains your target allocation as each asset class outperforms the other over time. For example, if stocks have surged, you’d sell some shares and redirect the proceeds to bonds to bring your holdings back to the desired percentages.
Key Takeaways on Comparing Stocks and Bonds
- Stocks offer part ownership in a company, while bonds are debt instruments that provide interest income.
- Stocks have historically delivered higher long-term returns, but with significant volatility.
- Bonds provide steady income with less price fluctuation but lower total returns.
- Key factors like time horizon, risk tolerance, and income needs impact the stock versus bond decision.
- Owning stocks and bonds together allows investors to benefit from growth and income with balanced risk.
Determining whether stocks or bonds are the better investment choice depends greatly on your individual financial situation and goals. Although stocks boast superior long-term returns, they require accepting higher volatility. Bonds offer stability and income, but with less upside potential. Maintaining a balanced portfolio with both stocks and bonds allows you to enjoy their complementary strengths while mitigating the risks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are stocks riskier than bonds?
Yes, stocks are considered riskier investments overall compared to bonds. Individual stock prices can experience huge swings up and down over weeks or months. Bonds tend to be more stable in price, though they are still not completely risk-free.
Do stocks or bonds pay more?
Over the long run, stocks have substantially higher total returns than bonds. The S&P 500 stock index has gained an average of around 10% annually over decades. Bonds typically return closer to 5-6% on average per year. However, bonds provide consistent interest income, while stock returns vary from year to year.
What returns more, stocks or real estate?
Historically, stocks have performed slightly better than residential real estate over time, with lower volatility. However, local real estate markets vary tremendously. Investing in rental properties, or REITs, can generate high returns for some real estate investors. Overall, stocks are easier to buy, sell, and diversify.
Should a 30 year old invest in stocks or bonds?
Younger investors should emphasize stocks over bonds in their portfolio. When you have three or four decades until retirement, the higher long-term growth potential of stocks outweighs their short-term volatility. Keeping the majority of your portfolio in stocks maximizes your ability to build wealth.
When should you shift from stocks to bonds?
As you move into your 50s and 60s, it makes sense to gradually reduce your allocation to stocks and increase your exposure to bonds. The precise timing depends on your risk tolerance and target retirement date. Many experts suggest moving 10% from stocks to bonds every 5-10 years as you approach your 60s. But even in retirement, holding some stocks is wise to maintain growth potential and beat inflation.
Can you lose money on bonds?
Yes, it is possible to lose money investing in bonds if you don’t hold them until maturity. The two main risks are interest rate changes and the bond issuer defaulting. If rates rise after you purchase a bond, its value will fall. You can end up losing principal if you are forced to sell at a lower price. Default risk means the issuer fails to repay part or all of what it owes you.
Which is better for passive income, stocks or bonds?
Bonds tend to be better than stocks for passive income investors who want regular cash flow. Bond interest payments are predictable and consistent, while stock dividend payments can fluctuate in amount and timing. One strategy is to use bond interest to cover living expenses while reinvesting stock dividends for growth.
Are stocks and bonds taxed differently?
Yes, different tax rates apply to income from stocks and bonds. Qualified stock dividends and long-term capital gains are taxed at special rates up to 20%. Bond interest income is taxed as ordinary income up to 37%. Municipal bond interest is an exception, as it is exempt from federal taxes.
What percentage of your portfolio should be in stocks vs bonds?
The right stock/bond allocation for you depends on factors like your age, risk tolerance, and time horizon. A good starting point is choosing a stock/bond percentage near your age. For example, at 35 years old, you might have 35% bonds and 65% stocks. As you get older, shift your portfolio to emphasize more bonds and fewer stocks.
In another related article, A Comprehensive Guide to Quantitative Bond Investing Strategies, Models and Techniques
Want to see what stocks the top hedge funds are looking at BEFORE it hits the mainstream news? Get free access for 7 days