You’re Probably Paying Too Much for Car Insurance (And Here’s Why)
The average American driver now pays $2,150 annually for full coverage auto insurance, and collision coverage makes up a significant portion of that cost. Yet most drivers don’t fully understand what they’re paying for or whether they even need it.
Here’s the truth: collision coverage can be your financial lifeline after an accident, but only if you choose the right policy at the right price. With insurance rates climbing 26% over the past three years, knowing exactly what collision coverage does (and doesn’t) protect can save you thousands while keeping you fully protected on the road.
What Is Collision Coverage? (And Why Every Driver Should Understand It)
Collision coverage is optional car insurance that pays to repair or replace your vehicle after it’s damaged in an accident with another car or object regardless of who caused the crash. Unlike liability insurance (which every state requires), collision coverage protects your own vehicle.
The Key Difference That Confuses Most Drivers
Think of it this way: Liability insurance protects other people from you. Collision coverage protects you from accidents.
If you rear-end another car, your liability insurance pays for their damages. Your collision coverage pays for your own car repairs. This distinction matters because 28,000+ collision claims are filed daily across America, and most drivers assume their basic policy covers everything.
What Does Collision Coverage Actually Cover?
Collision insurance kicks in for specific accident scenarios that could otherwise cost you $10,000 or more out of pocket:
Accidents with Other Vehicles
Whether you hit a moving car, sideswipe a parked vehicle, or get rear-ended at a stoplight, collision coverage handles the repairs to your car. This applies even in hit-and-run situations where the other driver flees the scene.
Single-Vehicle Accidents
Lost control on black ice and slid into a ditch? A tire blowout sent you into a guardrail? Brake failure caused you to crash? These single-vehicle accidents account for roughly 35% of all collision claims, and collision coverage pays for the damage.
Collisions with Stationary Objects
Hit a fence, telephone pole, concrete barrier, or highway divider? Collision coverage handles it. This also includes damage from hitting potholes, a growing problem that causes $3 billion in vehicle damage annually across the U.S.
Vehicle Rollovers
If your vehicle rolls over during an accident (whether you were hit or lost control), collision coverage pays for the extensive damage these incidents typically cause.
Temporary and Borrowed Vehicles
One underappreciated benefit: collision coverage often extends beyond your own car. If you’re driving a rental car while yours is in the shop or borrowing someone else’s vehicle, your collision coverage may apply. This can save you from purchasing expensive rental car insurance.
What Collision Coverage Doesn’t Cover (Avoid These Costly Mistakes)
Understanding the gaps in collision coverage prevents expensive surprises after an accident:
Damage You Cause to Others
If you hit another car, collision coverage only pays for your vehicle. The other driver’s car repairs come from your liability insurance. Injuries to other people? That’s bodily injury liability coverage, not collision.
Weather-Related Damage
Hail shattered your windshield? A tree branch fell on your car during a storm? Flooding damaged your engine? These fall under comprehensive coverage, not collision. This distinction trips up thousands of drivers annually who file claims under the wrong coverage.
Theft and Vandalism
If your car is stolen or vandalized with graffiti, comprehensive coverage handles it. Collision coverage only applies when your vehicle physically collides with something.
Animal Strikes
Hitting a deer, elk, or other animal requires comprehensive coverage. Collision coverage specifically excludes animal-related incidents, even though the impact damages your car similarly to other collisions.
Your Medical Expenses
Injured in an accident? Collision coverage pays for car repairs, not medical bills. You’ll need personal injury protection (PIP) or medical payments (MedPay) coverage for healthcare costs.
Damage from Civil Unrest
If your car is damaged during a protest, riot, or act of civil unrest, comprehensive coverage applies, not collision.
How Much Does Collision Coverage Cost in 2025?
Collision coverage typically costs between $290 and $650 annually, depending on multiple factors:
Factors That Determine Your Rate
Vehicle Value: Newer, more expensive vehicles cost more to insure. A 2024 Toyota Camry will have higher collision premiums than a 2015 Honda Civic.
Driving Record: One at-fault accident can increase your collision premium by 20-40% for three to five years.
Deductible Amount: Choosing a $1,000 deductible instead of $500 can reduce your premium by 15-30%.
Location: Urban areas with higher accident rates and repair costs see premiums 25-40% higher than rural locations.
Credit Score: In most states, better credit scores correlate with lower collision coverage costs.
The Real Cost of Going Without
Before dropping collision coverage to save money, consider this: The average collision claim in 2025 exceeds $5,200. Without coverage, you’re personally liable for every dollar. Can you afford to replace or repair your vehicle tomorrow if an accident happens?
Understanding Collision Coverage Deductibles (Choose Wisely)
Your deductible is the amount you pay before insurance covers the rest. Most policies offer deductibles from $250 to $2,000, and this choice significantly impacts both your premium and out-of-pocket costs after an accident.
How Deductibles Work in Real Scenarios
Example 1 – Minor Accident:
- Repair cost: $3,000
- Your deductible: $500
- Insurance pays: $2,500
- You pay: $500
Example 2 – Major Accident:
- Repair cost: $12,000
- Your deductible: $1,000
- Insurance pays: $11,000
- You pay: $1,000
Example 3 – Total Loss:
- Vehicle’s actual cash value: $18,000
- Your deductible: $1,000
- Insurance pays: $17,000
- You pay: $1,000
Choosing Your Ideal Deductible
Select a lower deductible ($250-$500) if:
- You have limited emergency savings
- You live in an area with high accident rates
- You drive frequently in heavy traffic
- Your vehicle is worth more than $15,000
Select a higher deductible ($1,000-$2,000) if:
- You have substantial emergency savings
- You have an excellent driving record
- You want lower monthly premiums
- Your lender doesn’t restrict deductible amounts
Do You Actually Need Collision Coverage? (The Honest Answer)
Whether collision coverage makes financial sense depends on your specific situation:
When Collision Coverage Is Required
Leased Vehicles: Leasing companies require full coverage, including collision, for the entire lease term.
Financed Vehicles: Banks and credit unions mandate collision coverage until your loan is paid off. Your lender holds your car as collateral and won’t risk losing that protection.
Business Vehicles: If you use your vehicle for business purposes, collision coverage often becomes necessary for liability protection and asset preservation.
When Collision Coverage Is Worth It (Even If Optional)
Your car is worth more than $4,000: If repairs would exceed your annual premium by a significant margin, keep collision coverage.
You can’t afford to replace your car: Even if your vehicle is older, collision coverage provides peace of mind if you don’t have savings for a replacement.
You drive in high-risk areas: Urban environments with heavy traffic, narrow streets, or high accident rates increase your collision risk substantially.
You have a poor driving record: If you’ve had recent accidents or violations, the likelihood of another claim makes collision coverage valuable.
When You Might Drop Collision Coverage
The “10% rule” helps here: If your annual collision premium exceeds 10% of your car’s actual cash value, consider dropping coverage.
For example, if your car is worth $3,000 and collision coverage costs $400 annually, you’re paying 13% of the car’s value for protection. Self-insuring might make more financial sense.
How to Compare Collision Coverage and Save Up to 30%
Insurance rates vary dramatically between providers, sometimes by $500+ annually for identical coverage. Here’s how to find the best deal:
Get Quotes from Multiple Insurers
Never settle for your first quote. Compare at least 3-5 providers, including:
- State Farm (handles 28,000+ claims daily)
- GEICO
- Progressive
- Allstate
- USAA (if you’re military-affiliated)
- Regional providers in your state
Bundle for Bigger Savings
Combining home and auto insurance with one provider typically saves 15-25% on both policies. Over 10 years, that’s thousands in savings.
Ask About Lesser-Known Discounts
Most insurers offer collision coverage discounts for:
- Safe driving history (no accidents for 3-5 years)
- Defensive driving course completion
- Anti-theft devices installed in your vehicle
- Low annual mileage (under 7,500 miles)
- Pay-in-full discounts (paying annually instead of monthly)
- Paperless billing and automatic payments
Review Your Policy Annually
Insurance rates change constantly. Review your coverage every 12 months to ensure you’re getting the best rate, especially as your vehicle depreciates.
Common Collision Coverage Mistakes That Cost Drivers Thousands
Mistake 1: Keeping the Same Deductible for Years
As your car ages and loses value, increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 can reduce premiums without significant risk.
Mistake 2: Not Understanding Actual Cash Value
When your car is totaled, insurers pay the actual cash value (ACV), not what you paid or what you owe. ACV accounts for depreciation, age, mileage, and condition. New cars lose 20% of their value in the first year alone.
Mistake 3: Assuming All Accidents Are Covered
Collision coverage has specific exclusions. Intentional damage, racing incidents, and using your vehicle for rideshare without proper coverage can void your claim.
Mistake 4: Filing Small Claims
If repair costs barely exceed your deductible, paying out of pocket often saves money long-term. Filing a claim can increase your premiums by 20-40% for years.
Mistake 5: Ignoring Gap Insurance
If you owe more on your car loan than the vehicle’s worth, collision coverage won’t cover that gap. Gap insurance protects you from this “upside-down” situation after a total loss.
Filing a Collision Coverage Claim: Step-by-Step
When an accident happens, knowing the claims process prevents delays and complications:
Immediately After the Accident
- Ensure Safety First: Check for injuries and call 911 if needed
- Document Everything: Take photos of all vehicle damage, the accident scene, license plates, and any debris
- Exchange Information: Get the other driver’s name, insurance details, and contact information
- File a Police Report: Even for minor accidents, police reports strengthen your claim
- Don’t Admit Fault: Let insurance companies determine liability
Starting Your Claim
Contact your insurer within 24-48 hours. Most major providers offer 24/7 claims support through apps, websites, or phone. You’ll need:
- Policy number
- Accident date, time, and location
- Description of what happened
- Police report number
- Photos and documentation
- Other driver’s information (if applicable)
The Claims Process
- Adjuster Assignment: Your insurer assigns a claims adjuster to assess the damage
- Vehicle Inspection: The adjuster inspects your car or reviews photos to estimate repair costs
- Repair Authorization: Once approved, you can take your vehicle to an approved repair shop
- Payment: After repairs, you pay your deductible and insurance covers the rest
Average claims processing takes 7-14 days for straightforward accidents, longer for disputes or total losses.
Collision vs. Comprehensive: Understanding Full Coverage
“Full coverage” isn’t an official insurance term, but it typically means liability plus collision plus comprehensive coverage. Here’s how collision and comprehensive differ:
| Coverage Type | Collision | Comprehensive |
| Accidents with vehicles | ✓ Covered | ✗ Not covered |
| Hitting objects | ✓ Covered | ✗ Not covered |
| Theft | ✗ Not covered | ✓ Covered |
| Vandalism | ✗ Not covered | ✓ Covered |
| Weather damage | ✗ Not covered | ✓ Covered |
| Animal strikes | ✗ Not covered | ✓ Covered |
| Fire/explosion | ✗ Not covered | ✓ Covered |
| Separate deductible | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
Most drivers benefit from having both coverages, but each addresses distinctly different risks.
State-Specific Considerations for Collision Coverage
While no state requires collision coverage by law, state regulations affect how it works:
No-Fault States
Michigan, Florida, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, and Utah operate under no-fault systems. In these states, your collision coverage (or PIP coverage) pays for your damages regardless of who caused the accident.
At-Fault States
In traditional at-fault states, the responsible driver’s insurance pays for damages. However, collision coverage still protects you when:
- The at-fault driver is uninsured or underinsured
- Fault is disputed
- You’re in a hit-and-run accident
- You caused the accident
High-Risk States
California, Florida, Louisiana, and Michigan have the highest collision claim frequencies. Drivers in these states particularly benefit from collision coverage due to elevated accident risk.
Take Action: Compare Collision Coverage Rates Today
Insurance rates fluctuate constantly based on market conditions, your driving record, and even your credit score. What you paid last year might not reflect today’s best available rates.
Don’t wait until after an accident to discover you’re underinsured or overpaying. Three simple steps protect your finances and your vehicle:
- Request quotes from at least 3-5 providers to compare collision coverage rates
- Review your current deductible and adjust based on your car’s current value
- Bundle policies to unlock maximum savings on both collision and comprehensive coverage
Rates change daily, and the difference between providers can exceed $50 monthly for identical coverage. Five minutes comparing quotes could save you $600+ annually while ensuring you have the protection you need.
Frequently Asked Questions About Collision Coverage
Is collision coverage the same as full coverage?
No. “Full coverage” typically refers to a combination of liability insurance, collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage together. Collision coverage is just one component that specifically handles accidents involving your vehicle colliding with another car or object.
Does collision coverage cover damage to other vehicles?
No. Collision coverage only pays for repairs to your own vehicle. Damage you cause to another person’s vehicle is covered by your property damage liability insurance, which is a separate required coverage.
When should I drop collision coverage on my car?
Consider dropping collision coverage when your car’s value falls below $4,000, or when your annual collision premium exceeds 10% of your vehicle’s actual cash value. Also evaluate your emergency savings; if you can afford to replace your car out of pocket, dropping coverage might make financial sense.
How much does collision coverage typically cost?
Collision coverage averages between $290 and $650 annually, though costs vary significantly based on your vehicle’s value, your driving record, your chosen deductible, and your location. Urban drivers typically pay 25-40% more than rural drivers.
Can I choose different deductibles for collision and comprehensive coverage?
Yes. Most insurers allow you to select separate deductibles for collision and comprehensive coverage. Many drivers choose a higher collision deductible (since they have more control over accidents) and a lower comprehensive deductible (since events like hail or theft are unpredictable).
Will my collision coverage pay for a rental car while mine is being repaired?
Not automatically. Collision coverage pays for vehicle repairs, but rental car reimbursement requires a separate rental coverage endorsement on your policy. Some collision policies do extend coverage to temporary substitute vehicles you’re driving.
Does collision coverage increase my premium after I file a claim?
Usually, yes. Filing an at-fault collision claim typically increases premiums by 20-40% for three to five years. However, some insurers offer accident forgiveness for your first at-fault accident if you’ve maintained a clean driving record.
Is collision insurance required by law in any state?
No state requires collision coverage by law. However, if you lease or finance your vehicle, your lender will require collision coverage as a condition of the loan or lease agreement until the vehicle is paid off.
What happens if my car is totaled and I still owe money on my loan?
Collision coverage pays the actual cash value of your vehicle, minus your deductible. If you owe more than this amount (called being “upside down”), you’re responsible for the difference unless you have gap insurance, which covers this shortfall.
Does collision coverage cover hitting a pothole?
Yes. Damage from hitting a pothole is covered under collision insurance because your vehicle collided with an object (the road surface). However, you’ll still need to pay your deductible, and filing a claim for minor pothole damage may not be cost-effective.
Can I add collision coverage to my policy at any time?
Yes, you can typically add collision coverage whenever you want, though it won’t retroactively cover past accidents. Some insurers may require a vehicle inspection before adding coverage to older vehicles to document pre-existing damage.
Does collision coverage apply when someone else is driving my car?
Generally, yes. Collision coverage typically follows the vehicle, not the driver. If you lend your car to someone and they have an accident, your collision coverage would apply to repair your vehicle. However, check your policy for any restrictions on permissive drivers.
Final Thought: Collision coverage represents a significant portion of your auto insurance budget, but it’s also the safety net that prevents a single accident from derailing your finances. By understanding exactly what it covers, choosing the right deductible, and comparing rates regularly, you ensure maximum protection at the lowest possible cost. Don’t leave money on the table; compare quotes today and drive with confidence knowing you’re properly protected.
In another related article, Struggling With Debt? A New Relief Program Is Helping Americans Reduce What They Owe — Fast
