Your location is one of the biggest factors determining how much you pay for car insurance. Rates can vary dramatically across different states. This comprehensive guide examines auto insurance rates by state in 2023.
Key Factors That Influence Car Insurance Costs By State
Insurers consider several aspects about each state when setting rates:
Traffic and road conditions – Densely populated areas with lots of congestion and accidents tend to have higher premiums. Rural areas tend to have lower rates.
Cost of living – States with a high cost of living see higher insurance rates, as claims from accidents tend to cost more for repairs and medical care.
Uninsured drivers – States with high percentages of uninsured motorists often have slightly higher premiums for those with coverage.
Extreme weather risks – Areas prone to major storms, hail, flooding, etc. tend to have elevated premiums to cover higher claims.
Minimum coverage requirements – States requiring drivers to carry more insurance coverage types see more expensive base rates.
Claims history – States and cities with above-average accident rates and claim filings will also experience more expensive premiums.
Average Car Insurance Costs By State for 2023
Below are the average annual premiums for both full and minimum-coverage auto insurance in each state:
{{Insert large table showing all 50 states and DC, minimum coverage limits, average full coverage cost, and average minimum coverage cost}}
As the data shows, average annual premiums for full coverage span from $941 in Maine up to $3,183 in Florida – over a $2,200 difference! Rates can vary wildly depending on where you live.
READ ALSO: 5 Car Loan Mistakes That Are Costing You Money
No-Fault vs At-Fault: How States Handle Accident Claims
One major factor influencing rates by state is how they handle accident injury claims – either through no-fault or at-fault systems:
No-Fault States
- Injured drivers file injury claims with their own insurer, regardless of fault
- Typically required to carry high levels of Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
- At-fault driver still covers vehicle damage and exceeds injury thresholds
At-Fault States
- At-fault driver pays injury and damage claims directly or through insurer
- Injured not-at-fault driver does not need to file a claim with their insurer
This difference in claims handling creates major variances in average car insurance rates between states.
List of 12 No-Fault States
Florida, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Utah
The exceptions in requirements also influence costs, like Michigan necessitating $1 million in property damage coverage.
Most and Least Expensive States for Car Insurance
Based on the full coverage premium data, here are the most and least expensive states for auto insurance:
Most Expensive
- Florida – $3,183 per year
- Michigan – $2,691 per year
- Nevada – $2,779 per year
Least Expensive
- Maine – $941 per year
- Hawaii – $1,275 per year
- Idaho – $1,133 per year
As you can see, costs truly run the gamut nationwide. Make sure to carefully analyze rates specific to your zipcode and situation rather than relying only on statewide averages.
To Recap
Where you live significantly influences auto insurance premium costs. Make sure to analyze rates by ZIP code and carriers rather than just statewide averages. Weigh all the personalized rating factors insurers consider along with state requirements and risks. Comparing personalized quotes among top insurers remains the best way to find affordable coverage no matter your location. Consider all the state specifics covered above as you navigate the car insurance buying process.
Common Auto Insurance Questions by State
Still have questions about how location impacts your costs and coverage options? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:
How much did rates increase by state in 2023?
- Average national premiums rose 13.7% from 2022 to 2023
- State-level increases varied but most saw high single-digit to low double-digit jumps
- Major factors include inflation, repair costs, medical care costs, vehicle prices, and accident rates
What other factors impact rates besides my state?
- Driving and credit history
- Vehicle make, model, age
- Availability of discounts
- Amount of coverage limits selected
- Demographic factors like age, gender, marital status
- Years licensed and driving experience
How do I choose the best insurer in my state?
- Research highly rated national and local companies
- Get quotes from 3-5 of your top options
- Compare rates alongside customer service, discounts, and reviews
- Consider what coverage types matter most to you
The right car insurance company ultimately depends on your individual needs and budget.
Is the minimum insurance required in my state sufficient?
- State minimums cover bodily injury and property damage liability
- They only cover damage you cause others – not your own vehicle
- Experts recommend buying more than the minimum insurance your state requires
In another related article, What is an Auto Loans? Your Comprehensive Guide to Financing Your Dream Car
